MMOSite

Sponsor

Richard Garriott's Response on Why "Most Game Designers Really Just Suck"

Read this post on other devices

By anselyouDate: Mar 22 2013 Views:

AWESOME

Responses
Your Reaction?

Recently, Richard Garriott has been in the eye of the storm because of his some fairly inflammatory statement in an interview with PC Gamer on March 19th. Lord British, more visible in the press these days as a result of his successful Shroud of the Avatar Kickstarter project, sat down with the mag to talk a lot about what ails gaming and who he thinks is capable of doing something about it.


Garriott said, "I've met virtually no one in our industry who I think is close to as good a game designer as I am. I'm not saying that because I think I'm so brilliant. What I'm saying is, I think most game designers really just suck, and I think there's a reason why." He cited a lack of education and a lack of extra-design skills as problems plaguing many designers and the industry at large.


If you're not a good artist and not a good programmer, but you still like games, you become a designer, if you follow me.
You get into Q&A and often design. And the most valuable part of creating a game is the design, which the programmers are technically executing. And they'd be happy to just execute some of them. But in my mind, most artists and programmers are just as much of gamers as the designers, and I usually find in my history that the artists and programmers are, in fact, as good of designers as the designers. They're often better, because they understand the technology or the art.
So we're leaning on a lot of designers who get that job because they're not qualified for the other jobs, rather than that they are really strongly qualified as a designer. It's really hard to go to school to be a good designer."


This statement, and others like it that were delivered in the interview, caused no small amount of backlash. On March 20th, Garriott posted a response, titled as "Words taken out of context" in an attempt to "clarify" his words. He blame that a lack of context and "broader real time discussion" for the simplification and inaccurate representations of his statements. "By no means did I intend to disparage others who have led the many great games of each era in gaming history." he said. Then he went on explain his ideas on "why finding or growing NEW great game designers is hard" by comparing being a designer versus being an artist or programmer. He believed that the good designers have to be good at drawing and coding. Although there are now at least a few good schools like the Guildhall at SMU, that turn out quality designers, but "these quality designers remain a rare breed". "Sadly," he concludes, "I really do think that most people who get into design roles on a team have no more skills at design than the programmers and artists."

Lest we do him the disservice of taking his words out of context, you can read his full rebuttal at the Portalarium website.

 

Richard Garriott's news really made me great interested in game design. I googled a lot the "skills for game designer". To sum up, I think there are at least five skills need to acquire:
1.Computer Programming including Mathematics
2.Artistic skills and techniques
3.A detailed knowledge of current popular games and consoles as well as the history of games
4.Strong written and communication skills
5.A very strong sense to know what make a game good or bad

The last one is most important one? Yes, it should be. It must be the most difficult one. Looking at my list, I feel happy that I am not a game designer, even never dreaming about it. :D


Source:Portalarium, PCGAMER

Bookmark and share to your friends

Submit News & Articles

Write Now

Special Offer

Writer Club Staff

  • Icaras Icaras Elite Columnist
    Articles ?

    Icaras can be best described as a British gamer who gets a little too into PvP. He can be found playing any RPG with PvP features...

  • Raptorak Raptorak Advanced Columnist
    Articles ?

    Raptorak is an avid gamer that enjoys exploring all aspects of games. While doing so, he immerses himself into the surrounding community...

  • Zevri Zevri Advanced Columnist
    Articles ?

    Zevri is an avid gamer who does dive back into the real world from time to time. His all time goal is to start his own business...

  • Ron Fair Ron Fair Advanced Columnist
    Articles ?

    Ron Fair is a very passionate writer and scholar whose strong and sometimes unconventional opinions have stirred controversy...

  • chaose5 chaose5 Elite Columnist
    Articles ?

    Chaose5 is an avid MMORPG player from Singapore. He is one of the founders and leader of the largest English speaking guild...

  • Mimiron Mimiron Advanced Columnist
    Articles ?

    I really like to share my views with the world, thus, passion to Blizzard franchises brought me here...

  • Benjamin Benjamin Elite Columnist
    Articles ?

    He keep an eye of the things going around the communities in the mmo games, and general games, also getting whatever info he can get into his hands...

  • Although he has a bachelor's degree in Criminology, Alex has been writing about video games for over four years. He is a producer, indie developer, and hardcore gamer...

  • LamestDude LamestDude Elite Columnist
    Articles ?

    LamestDude loves to play MMORPGs. They are indeed one of his passions beside the other one, which is writting...

  • Aspenach Aspenach Elite Columnist
    Articles ?

    Aspenach is a gamer who loves variety in his games and games he plays includes, FPS, RPG, Action Games, Driving Games and lately MMORPG...

  • David is an avid gamer, but loves RPGs and especially MMOs the most of all. He particularly enjoys playing Paladin/Guardian-esque characters...

  • DJWest DJWest Newbie Writer
    Articles ?

    DJWest is a long-time MMO fan who loves high-speed action, healing, and large-scale battles that make you think...

  • Net Net Newbie Writer
    Articles ?

    Net enjoys the fun and satisfaction of shooter games, but has been known to enjoy playing Thief-type characters in RPGs....

Mobile Game News

Five Hot Japanese Anime Themed Mobile Games Five Hot Japanese Anime Themed Mobile Games
  • E3
  • ChinaJoy
  • Comic Con
  • GamesCom
  • Gstar
  • GDC
  • PAX East